Member-only story
Timberly Claytor
Murdered and Missing Women of Ohio Part 11
Trigger Warning: Murder, Sex, Drugs
Unlike the other Chillicothe, Ohio women, Timberly Claytor wasn’t missing on May 29th, 2015, when her body was found behind the old dairy bar on Trego Creek Road in Massieville. Everyone thought Tiffany Sayre had been found. Some of Tiffany’s family showed up at the crime scene, but her tattoos were not the same, and she was ruled out before the body was even moved.
They soon named the victim, Timberly Claytor of Chillicothe. She was a mother of five, and her life was cut short by one, Jason McCrary, a convicted sex offender.
We wouldn’t know anything about this crime if it weren’t for Timberly’s friend Jessica Lowry. She was terrified when she walked into the Chillicothe Police Department on May 30th, but she knew what she had to do, and she did it.
Timberly, Jessica, Jason, and a few other people were drinking and doing drugs together on May 28th, 2015. Jessica, trembling, told the jury that Jason drove everyone to Scioto Trails Park in southern Ross County. While they were there, Jason and Timberly had sex and did more drugs. When they all got back into the car and headed back to Chillicothe, Jason got angry at Timberly.
“Jason got mad at Timberly for smoking the last bit of crack. He called her a…
